Canadian Pinot Noir: Time to call Bullsh*t

Canadian Pinot Noir: Busting the Bullsh*t Myth of Expensive, Unloved Wines

Pinot Noir has long been the darling of wine connoisseurs—a delicate, complex red that beautifully reflects the region it comes from. Traditionally, wine lovers gravitate toward Burgundy, California, or Oregon when seeking top-tier Pinot Noir, but there’s a rising star that deserves more attention: Canadian Pinot Noir.

Despite lingering misconceptions that Canadian wines are overpriced or inferior, the reality tells a different story. A closer look at Vivino scores and pricing at the LCBO (Liquor Control Board of Ontario) shows that Canadian Pinot Noir competes impressively with its international counterparts in both quality and value.

The Numbers Don’t Lie: Canadian Pinot Noir Holds Its Own

Vivino scores provide valuable insight into a wine’s quality, based on thousands of consumer reviews. A breakdown of Pinot Noir options at the LCBO reveals that Canadian Pinot Noir is not only competitive—it’s a smart choice for value and excellence.

What the Data Shows:

• Flat Rock Cellars Pinot Noir ($24.95, 3.6) competes directly with Kim Crawford and Bourgogne Pinot Noir (Jadot), which have identical ratings but are from New Zealand and France.

• Hidden Bench Estate Pinot Noir ($34.95, 3.8) matches La Crema Monterey Pinot Noir, proving that Canadian wines are on par with premium international selections.

• G Marquis Silver Line Stone Road ($19.95, 3.8) is a fantastic deal, comparable in quality to Rodney Strong Russian River ($29.95) and La Crema Sonoma Coast ($19.95).

• Finally, our Westcott Pinot Noir with a Vivino score of 4.0 and a price of $32.95 compares favourably with all comers on the list

Why Canadian Pinot Noir Deserves More Love

Despite its quality, US Pinot Noirs dominate sales at the LCBO, making up over 70% of category sales. This is more a reflection of consumer habit than wine superiority. The outdated belief that “Canadian wines aren’t as good” simply doesn’t hold up against the facts. Canadian winemakers have mastered the craft and are producing Pinot Noirs that showcase the country’s incredible terroir.

The Niagara Effect: A World-Class Pinot Noir Region

• So, what makes Canadian Pinot Noir special? It starts with the land. The Niagara Peninsula’s cool climate is ideal for Pinot Noir, with its unique mix of cold winters, warm summers, and limestone-rich soils. These conditions mirror those of Burgundy, the birthplace of Pinot Noir, making Niagara one of the world’s most underrated wine regions.

Some of Canada’s top Pinot Noir producers—including Flat Rock Cellars, Hidden Bench, Tawse, and Cave Spring—have spent years perfecting their craft. The result? Bright cherry and raspberry flavors, a touch of earthiness, and well-integrated acidity—all hallmarks of great Pinot Noir.

The Value Proposition: Why You Should Buy Canadian Pinot Noir

The price comparison table makes one thing clear: Canadian Pinot Noir offers exceptional value.

Take Tawse Pinot Noir Growers Blend ($29.95, 3.7). It stands toe-to-toe with A to Z Pinot Noir from Oregon ($31.95, 3.7) at a lower price. Similarly, Hidden Bench Estate Pinot Noir ($34.95, 3.8) delivers the same level of quality as La Crema Monterey—while keeping your dollars in Canada.

By choosing Canadian Pinot Noir, you’re not just getting an outstanding bottle of wine—you’re also supporting local winemakers who are pushing the industry forward. With every purchase, you help these wineries refine their craft, expand production, and gain the recognition they deserve.

Conclusion: Time for Canada to Own Its Excellence 

The myth that Canadian Pinot Noir is overpriced or inferior doesn’t hold up under scrutiny. With Vivino scores that match top US and European brands and pricing that remains competitive, there’s never been a better time to embrace Canadian wine.

Canadian Pinot Noir captures the country’s unique terroir, craftsmanship, and potential. The next time you’re shopping for wine, skip the familiar US or French labels and reach for a bottle of Canadian Pinot Noir. You just might discover your new favourite wine.

Share Your Westcott Experience!

We love seeing your wine tasting memories! Share your photos and experiences with us on Instagram by tagging @WestcottVineyards and using the hashtag #WestcottWines.

If you enjoyed your visit, we’d greatly appreciate your Google review—it helps others discover the magic of Westcott! Leave a Review Here.